Facebook

Chris Pickett's Facebook profile

Saturday, 17 March 2007

Games turn kids into killers...

...Or never let the facts get in the way of the chance to hang blame on someone.

Despite the paranoia of the tabloids, the chances of getting shot, stabbed or even blown up when popping down the shops, is still very small. The UK remains a relatively safe place to live. For example, the number or deaths due to stabbing has remained relatively constant for the last ten years.

However, that must be small comfort to the family of Kodjo Yenga as they grieve for their son. And it is natural for the “general public” (whoever they are) to be shocked by such stories and also to wish for someone to come up with both an explanation and an answer.

But no one is helped by apportioning blame where it doesn’t lie or by suggesting quick fix solutions that won’t work.

Radio Four’s “Mr News”, John Humphreys, conducted an interview (listen) this morning, with an expert on knife crime. What made him an expert was of course never really explained – he had “written” on the subject, we were told.

And as you would expect, he trotted out the usual material. These youths carry knives because – they are concerned for their safety or there is nothing for them to do or they live in deprived areas or poor parenting or… well, you get the idea.

However, our John had other ideas; it’s down to violent video games, says he. And surely we can do something about them! What he means, of course, is ban them.

Now, OK, if a half hour on Battlefield 2142 or Counterstike could be shown to cause kids to pick up their Scar 11 or AK47s and hit the streets, perhaps there is a debate to be had over this. Mind you, then we would also have to ban The Sims – good grief, all that woohoo going on!!!

But what Mr Humphreys conveniently forgets to mention (as did his expert guest) is that there is no clear evidence of any such link. On top of that, do we know if the group now charged with the crime even have a computer or games consol let alone whether they are “obsessed” with games, violent or not? Of course we don’t but that won’t worry the BBC. If it turns out that copies of the games that work him into such a frenzy are found at these kids’ houses, you can bet John will report it. On the other hand if it turns out that they pass the time reading Jane Austin and playing the violin, will he withdraw his accusation.

If this rubbish were being spouted in a pub, it wouldn’t matter, but this is being broadcast to millions of people – repeatedly. Say it enough times and of course people believe it.

Of course, politicians are no better.

Witness David (call me Dave) Cameron’s wacky idea to force absent fathers to live with their children and ex-partners. As if that will foster good parenting!






Despite its (thankfully) rarity, such crime is so shocking that we need to look at whether we can do anything to make it even less common.

But, for heavens sake, let us have a proper debate on the subject. Let us find out if there is anything we can do.

I guess the problem is that if we did so, the answers won’t be so conveniently simple and those who the real blame lies with might not be a nice convenient group such as gamers or even absent fathers.

God forbid that any responsibility might lie with successive governments or even the media!!



2 comments:

Simon said...

Oh darling how purrrrfect to find you back on the net where you belong. I've really missed you since the tellytubbies finished, so more power to you little purple elbow and your heavenly "cat flap". I too am enchanted by that old Silver Fox John Humphreys, gosh what a dish he is, although between you and me tinkey I hold a torch for that cuddly ball of fluff Geoff Beard on the bona fidey BBC. He can interview me anytime. But hark at me my purple warrior of the truth coming over all girly and feline hot under my corset. Just wanted to give you a big Glenda Mr Whiskers to your campaign against Radio 4 and those nasty computor games. I too think its criminal what they are doing. Last time I went into Game they had the cheek to charge little old me £39.99 for the latest Super Mario. I tell you Tinks, if I may be so over familiar for a Laydeeee, if thats not enough for someone to murder the little smug assistant I dont know what is!!! But enough of my silly goings on. Just to say love the new page and you Go Cat!!

Love Glenda xx

Glenda said...

P.S. Oh darling, silly me, forgot to say treat yourself to an eatra large saucer of milk you clever Tom

Love Glenda xx